What is Reciprocity Failure?


"Lower Manhattan Glowing" - by Shawn Hoke, via FPP Flickr Pool

Whether you’re using a lower speed film in daylight, trying to maximize your depth of field in a landscape, or just setting up the camera for an exposure at night, sooner or later you’re going to start pushing the limits of your film’s light gathering ability. As light becomes more scarce, the silver halide grains residing in your film will be less uniformly struck by photons, causing a steep drop in density after a few seconds of needed exposure. This exponentially diminishing response to low light levels is more popularly known as a film’s reciprocity failure. Not all films are created equal, and some will respond better than others, but here’s what you can typically expect:

B&W Film - exposures in excess 1-2 seconds will result in reduced density, yielding very thin, if not non-existent shadows.

Color Negative Film - exposures in excess of 20 seconds will result in color-shifting, as dye layers of the film will absorb light unevenly over the prolonged exposure.

Slide Film - exposures in excess of 5 seconds have color shifts similar to color negative. In high saturation films such as Fuji Velvia, this shifting is much more extreme.


"We Saw It Happen" - by Kevin Joes, via FPP Flickr Pool

So how can we avoid the “Effffed!” moment after getting our images developed? Compensation, compensation, compensation! In B&W films, you compensate by adding more exposure time, and developing slightly less time. In color emulsions, you add slightly more time, and apply color filtration to compensate for color shifts. But to what degree to we make these changes? Luckily, chemical engineers and other well trained film professionals have rigorously tested films before bringing them to market. Almost every major film out there gives us a general use data sheet, telling us what working exposures we can expect from a given metered scene. Take, for example, this lovely chart (page 2) for Kodak’s classic B&W film, Tri-X.

Dissecting B&W exposure compensation a little more, why is it necessary to reduce development time if we’re already increasing the exposure time? The simple answer is to save highlights. During that longer exposure, photons hitting the film emulsion in the highlight region will give the silver halides plenty of light. To make sure there’s still some detail in the final image’s highlights, you reduce the development time; this will give the shadows adequate time to develop while taming just how dense the highlights get. In other words, we’re taking a very high contrast exposure and applying a low contrast development to obtain a “normal” negative. For more information and much more on exposure and development, I highly recommend Ansel Adams’ The Negative.


"Patiently Waiting" - by Jeff Soderquist, via FPP Flickr Pool

If anything here is starting to sound too technical, have no fear. Remember that a vast majority of the pictures you’ll be taking won’t even need to consider reciprocity failure. But if you regularly shoot at night or with a large format camera, however, you may want to get to know your film a little better with a five minute “Da Google” search. A couple other ways to “cheat” reciprocity failure is to shoot with a film stock that has very low reciprocity failure or responds well to color shifting. In the B&W world, the hot film for long exposures the past couple of years has been Fuji Across 100. For exposures 2 minutes or less (that’s right, 2 minutes!), no compensation is needed. For anything after that only needs ½ stop adjustment or 1.5 times the indicated exposure time. For color film shooters a, now harder to find, popular solution was to shoot slower speed tungsten balanced slide film such as Ektachrome 64T for a really long time, as the shifts would lean more towards daylight, no filtering required! You can see a great example below:


Puerto Madero, Buenos Aires, Argentina - by Rafakoy, via FPP Flickr Pool

So now that you’re in “the know” on reciprocity failure, get out there any time of day and shoot. Stop all the way down in broad daylight, shoot with ridiculously slow film in low light, and even play around with color shifts. Just use that trusty tripod, remember the pros and cons of your film, stay super positive, and have fun! And when you get those tasty film images developed, be sure to head over to the Film Photography Project’s Flickr Group, and post ‘em there too.

Happy shooting and long live film.

Reciprocity failure is discussed on Episode 45 – October 15, 2011 of The Film Photography Podcast!

Comments

Jean-Pierre's picture
Great info and awesome long exposure examples. Thanks!
Dan Domme's picture

If anyone is curious, reciprocity essentially refers to the fact that a stop of aperture and a stop of shutter speed are one and the same.  That is, they have a reciprocal relationship.  So a shot at f/16 and 1/125 of a second has the exact same exposure as a shot at f/11 and 1/250 of a second.  In fact, that's why the EV scale works.  Exposure is constant at a given EV, no matter what the specific aperture and shutter speed is.

Reciprocity failure, then, is just when you don't get a full stop of exposure at the longer exposure times.  In geek terms, it's a nonlinear system.  But as Mat says, at that point it's just a matter of looking up the datasheet of the film you have and applying the appropriate correction.

fish_kite's picture

You will also see reciprocity law failure when you have a combination of high light intensity and/or a very short shutter speed. This is most often encountered in high-speed photography.

Sir David's picture
It seems like a million years since I was in school learning this. Always nice to brush up on things like reciprocity failure. Thanks and Keep up the good work.
Martin Bruntnell's picture
Have a look at Edgar Martins photographs of the USA housing crash some of those are up to 4 hours long,taken with sheet film.One was around 12 feet wide and superbly sharp,could not see any reciprocity failure.
Nathan's picture
Chaps, you should have mentioned Provia 100f, which also has a time of a whopping 127 seconds before correction.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.